We tested 18 indoor grills side-by-side to find the best for searing, smoke control, and easy cleanup.
The Ninja Foodi AG301 combines air frying and grilling with a powerful 500°F max temperature. It produces excellent grill marks and has a large capacity, though the lid can be tricky to clean.
This affordable indoor grill reaches 450°F for proper searing and has a large 118-square-inch surface. The removable plates are dishwasher-safe, but the lid doesn't fully contain smoke.
The Cuisinart Griddler is a versatile countertop grill and griddle with reversible plates. It opens flat for double the cooking area, but the plates can be cumbersome to remove.
The George Foreman grill is a budget-friendly classic that drains fat and cooks quickly. It lacks precise temperature control and doesn't get hot enough for a hard sear.
Philips' infrared grill claims to reduce smoke by up to 90% while reaching 446°F. It performs well for fish and vegetables, but the high price and bulky design may deter some.
The Griddler Deluxe offers six cooking options and a large 240-square-inch surface when opened flat. It heats evenly and has a built-in drip tray, but it's heavy and takes up counter space.
This XL Ninja grill features a 500°F max temperature and a large 100-square-inch surface with a griddle insert. It's excellent for family meals but is quite large for small kitchens.
The Breville Smart Grill uses embedded heating elements for precise temperature control and has a 'plate temperature' display. It's a premium option with excellent build quality, but the price is high.
This budget-friendly grill opens flat to become a full griddle and includes a panini press mode. It heats up quickly but struggles to maintain high temperatures for extended periods.
The T-fal OptiGrill uses sensor technology to automatically adjust cooking time based on thickness. It's convenient for beginners, but the nonstick coating can wear over time.
Affiliate disclosure: Links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.