We tested 18 popular nut butters for taste, texture, and ingredient quality to bring you the top picks.
Smooth, creamy texture with a rich roasted peanut flavor. Made with high-quality ingredients and no added sugar or palm oil.
A delicious blend of seven nuts and seeds, providing a complex, nutty flavor. Perfect for those who want more than just peanut butter.
Smooth and creamy with a pure, natural almond taste. Made from organic dry roasted almonds, perfect for spreading or baking.
A great nut-free alternative for those with allergies, with a mild, creamy sunflower seed flavor. Smooth and spreadable.
Artisan-style peanut butter with generous crunchy peanut pieces for a satisfying bite. Made from high-quality peanuts and a touch of sea salt.
Simple, honest peanut butter with a smooth, creamy texture. Made with only one ingredient: dry roasted peanuts.
Silky smooth and naturally sweet, this raw cashew butter is a luxurious treat. Perfect for those seeking a mild, buttery flavor.
A clean, smooth almond butter with a fine grind that spreads easily. Made from blanched almonds for a creamier texture.
A UK favorite with a robust peanut flavor and satisfying crunch. Made with a hint of sea salt to enhance the taste.
A great value option with a pure peanut taste and smooth texture. Comes in a large 2-pack, perfect for families.
Affiliate disclosure: Links on this page are affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.